How to Choose the Right Structure for Your Business ?
“What’s the right structure for my business?” is one of the most common questions our clients ask. There’s no single answer. It depends on who owns the business, how you plan to grow, and what you want in the long run. This page walks through the main things to think about.
START SIMPLE: THE SOLE PROPRIETORSHIP
If you’re starting a new business on your own (a married couple counts as one owner), a sole proprietorship is often the best place to start. It’s the simplest and least expensive option.
Two things to keep in mind:
1. Protect yourself.
Talk with your attorney about liability, and make sure you have enough business insurance.
2. An LLC or corporation won’t fully shield you from business debts.
Most lenders and landlords ask for a personal guarantee anyway, so you’ll usually still be personally responsible for those debts.
WHEN TO CONSIDER AN LLC OR CORPORATION
A sole proprietorship works for many new businesses, but sometimes an LLC (Limited Liability Company) or a corporation is the better choice. Each one has its own tax and non-tax pros and cons. We’ll help you weigh them against your situation, your liability concerns, and your long-term goals.
The situations below can help point you in the right direction.
1. YOU HAVE MORE THAN ONE OWNER
Get a written agreement. If two or more people own the business, put your arrangement in writing from day one. It should cover:
* How income and expenses are split
* Whether owners get paid a salary, and how much
* What happens if an owner dies or becomes disabled
* Differences in benefits, such as health insurance or retirement contributions
* How you’ll handle it if the business needs more money
Agreeing on these points at the start helps prevent disputes later. This agreement is usually drawn up when you form a partnership, corporation, or LLC, and you should have a qualified business attorney help you write it.
Note: Corporations have stricter recordkeeping rules than LLCs. This matters more when some owners hold only a small share of the business (minority shareholders).
2. OWNERS PUT IN DIFFERENT AMOUNTS
Sometimes one owner contributes more cash or equipment than the others. In that case, it may be fair to split profits or depreciation in a way that reflects each person’s investment.
* Partnerships and LLCs: These uneven splits (“special allocations”) are generally allowed.
* S corporations: Not allowed. Every shareholder must have equal rights to distributions and to proceeds if the business is closed or sold.
3. YOU WANT TO REDUCE PAYROLL TAXES
S corporation owners pay payroll taxes and income tax on the salary they take. Profits left over after salary are generally subject to income tax only, which can lower your total payroll taxes.
For a more detailed side-by-side look, see our page comparing S corporations and LLCs.
4. YOU’RE WORRIED ABOUT YOUR PARTNERS’ ACTIONS
In a general partnership, you can be personally liable for what your partners do. An LLC or corporation can help limit that risk.
5. YOU PLAN TO GO PUBLIC OR SELL THE BUSINESS
A C corporation is often the preferred choice if you plan to bring in investors, go public, or sell.
Advantages:
* Investors are generally more comfortable with C corporations.
* Owners who sell qualifying corporate stock may get tax benefits. If a sale is possible, work with an experienced tax advisor early to make sure your stock qualifies.
Disadvantages:
* Income can be taxed twice when the business is closed: once at the corporate level and again when owners receive the money.
* C corporations pay a flat 21% corporate tax rate, which may be higher than what many small business owners would pay otherwise.
* C corporations don’t qualify for the Section 199A deduction (the deduction for qualified business income).
Because of this, C corporations are often less attractive for small businesses.
6. YOUR BUSINESS NEEDS A STATE LICENSE (CALIFORNIA)
California limits some licensed businesses from forming LLCs. The problem is that the state hasn’t clearly said which licenses count as “professional” (restricted) and which count as “nonprofessional.”
What this means for you:
* If your business needs a state license and your type of license hasn’t been clearly addressed, your LLC could be challenged later. This usually comes up during a lawsuit.
Contractors:
* The Contractors State License Board does allow contractors to operate as LLCs, but with extra requirements, such as carrying $1 million in liability insurance or holding $500,000 in liquid assets.
* Because of these requirements, LLCs are more common among larger contracting businesses.
7. YOU EXPECT BUSINESS LOSSES
In a partnership, LLC, or S corporation, profits and losses “pass through” to the owners’ personal tax returns. But you can only deduct losses up to your “basis,” which is roughly how much you’ve invested in the business.
* Partnerships and LLCs: Owners can count their share of the company’s debt as part of their basis. This can let them deduct more losses.
* S corporations: Shareholders generally can’t count the company’s debt as basis. The exception is money the shareholder lends to the company directly.
Because of this, holding rental real estate in an S corporation is usually not a good idea.
8. YOUR SALES ARE $250,000 OR MORE (CALIFORNIA)
California charges LLCs an extra fee once gross receipts reach $250,000. The fee ranges from $900 to $11,790.
Corporations don’t pay this fee, so a corporation may make more sense for businesses with sales above $250,000.
OTHER FACTORS TO CONSIDER
Many other things can affect your choice, including:
* Fringe benefits
* Personal service corporation status
* Personal holding company status
* Owners who live outside the U.S.
* The benefit of using a fiscal year that ends on a date other than December 31
* Wanting to build up cash inside the company
* Estate planning
Here is more information on the differences between LLCs and S corporations.
The purpose of this information is to highlight key considerations and help you start a discussion with your tax accountant and attorney.
EZ-Accounting LLC
A member of AIPB – Membership#: 003001121
A member of CTEC – # A350918
2027 – AFSP-Completion



